Three Practical Tips for Integrating GenAI into your Writing Pedagogy without Sacrificing Critical Thinking and Creativity
As Generative Artificial Intelligence, or GenAI, spreads through schools rapidly, writing instructors worry about how the new technology will affect their teaching. GenAI will change education forever; the very standards teachers have used for generations to measure students’ comprehension in English classes, like essays and term papers, can now be written in the blink of an eye with just a few simple prompts. However, while ChatGPT and the like may be able to imitate some common academic writing styles, they lack the ability to form original thoughts. GenAI also instantly arrives at an output, without going through the trial and error that human students experience through drafting and revision. Since GenAI essays tend to be generic and surface level in their analyses, teachers can continue to assign essays to check for higher level critical thinking—they just need to communicate with students, trust them, and reorient assignments to prioritize progress over product.
In his article “Faithful Writing Pedagogy in the Age of Generative AI: A Sabbath-Grounded Approach,” Treynor Hansen shares three practical ways to integrate GenAI into your teaching of lower-level writing classes to inspire helpful writing habits and processes in your students.
#1 Clarify the boundaries of Academic Honesty with GenAI
Some teachers treat all and any AI usage as plagiarism or cheating and ban it entirely. After all, the tool’s ethics around copyright and intellectual property are currently under scrutiny and debate, since GenAI writes by mimicking texts in its dataset without citing those original texts. But before AI, students reached out to writing tutors, editing programs, or Youtube for help with specific parts of the writing process. AI doesn’t have to automatically mean plagiarism—the student’s academic integrity depends on how they use the tool. Students can unethically claim a paper written in a few prompts by GenAI, or they can center human writing choices and use GenAI as a tutor to revise different elements of the paper. While students should write the first draft themselves, fine tuning the paper with outside materials isn’t commonly considered cheating. AI can provide 24/7 help with strengthening a thesis, macro or micro organization, or a final grammar check before students turn the paper in. Personally, GenAI has given me the second pair of eyes to look over my paper before I turn it in just before the deadline.
Instead of assuming students will plagiarize papers by prompting GenAI to write them, communicate with them. Lay out clear examples of acceptable GenAI use that follows the school’s policy on Academic Integrity.
By interacting with GenAI and comparing their multi-step writing to GenAI’s immediate output, students have an opportunity to learn how to be skeptical of AI-generated writing. This will not only develop their critical thinking skills but help them value their own writing abilities above a computer’s. They can learn to value the process of writing and see how much more complex, nuanced, and original the product of human trial and error is than an instant mimicry of other scholars’ writing published on the internet.
#2 Teach Authenticity and Trust
On the first day of many writing classes, academic integrity is always on the agenda. The consequences of plagiarism are typically clearly outlined in a course’s syllabus: an F, a suspension, or even expulsion. I certainly feel fear in my heart when this slide of the syllabus is pulled up. But with the rise of AI, I feel both fear and confusion about plagiarism. Teaching students how to use GenAI while avoiding plagiarism would benefit both teachers and students. This would include showing students how to cite or acknowledge their use of GenAI tools. Teachers, too, need to cite AI if they use it in their lessons.
According to Hansen, “Openness starts with professors’ transparency about their own practices.” This means writing instructors being transparent about using AI for lesson planning, powerpoints, or discussion questions. Hearing my writing instructors talk about how they use AI in their teaching would make me as a student more comfortable with how to use it myself.
#3 Prioritize the Process First, Product Second
Writing is hard! Part of teaching writing is stirring intrinsic motivation, resilience, and hope to work through the confusion and vulnerability involved in the muddled process of writing. But in writing, there is so much possibility for character building and self-discovery. Writing instructors ultimately want to help students discover their individual writing process. One way to make this daunting task more approachable to students and less susceptible to inappropriate uses of GenAI is to scaffold writing assignments or break them down into multiple, bite-sized chunks with lower stakes. Hansen elaborates that “low-stakes assignments can also include revision components that allow students to develop flexible thinking around a topic, encounter more complexity and a more comprehensive range of perspectives, and try out different arguments along the way to producing a stronger finished paper.” The grading for these scaffolded assignments is more casual, and students are able to work with each other, emphasizing the social element of writing. I know in classes where my assignments consisted of in-class partner work, peer reviews, and one-on-one conferences with my instructor, I felt supported in my writing, and before I knew it I had a beautiful formal paper completed.
In short, students may not jump so quickly to using GenAI in writing assignments if they feel supported in a hospitable learning environment. Learning to integrate the new technology into assignments while still emphasizing critical and original thinking will have a learning curve for writing instructors, but with an open mind, trust in their students, and clear communication, they can maintain the focus on teaching the writing process, instead of the outcome.
Post Author